The member community is live — and a Fourth of July essay to read your way in.

A lot has landed at once. The community we’ve been building is finally open, and there’s a Fourth of July essay I want in your hands — on the country we could still choose to be. Start with the doors.

THE COMMUNITY IS OPEN

A guided map through the whole of women’s health — Packs & Playbooks that tell you what to do in a real appointment, Labora Rounds being built in the open, and our work dropped where you see it first and can write back to me directly.

Every current subscriber gets 3 months free.

A FOURTH OF JULY ESSAY

A nation founded on an idea — and the pattern that has shadowed it ever since

There is a version of this country that has never existed. Every so often we have tried to build it.

The founders drew the blueprint, contradictions and all — men writing that all are created equal while they held people as property. What they set down still indicts us.

Then the Civil War tore it open, and Reconstruction tried to actually build the thing. Black legislators. Black voters. Schools. The machinery of a real multiracial democracy assembled in a handful of years by people who had been property a decade before. It is easy to forget how close it came. Easier still to forget it happened at all, because of what came after.

What came after was slaughter. The backlash to Reconstruction wasn't a disagreement. It was a campaign of terror that rolled back nearly everything and installed a century of apartheid dressed up as law. The next attempt was the civil rights movement, and that one held longer — you could argue it held all the way to Obama, the high-water mark of a certain kind of hope. Now we're somewhere else. Now we're in the backlash again.

That's the pattern, if you're willing to see it. A push toward the more perfect union, then a violent recoil from it. Founding and Reconstruction. Civil rights and its long unwinding. We are living inside the recoil right now, and the only open question is whether the recoil becomes the whole story.

Power concedes nothing without a demand — and the wall that makes this so hard

Go looking through history for a time a dominant group shared power freely — not because it was forced to, but because it chose to — and you mostly come up empty. Reach all the way back to Rome and you find something close: an empire that grew partly because it kept widening the circle of citizenship, taking in the peoples it met instead of just ruling them. But Rome isn't the clean example we want. It enfranchised its Italian allies only after they revolted, and the great universal grant centuries later was, more than anything, a way to tax more people. Inclusion was a tactic, squeezed out under pressure. Not a gift.

The modern near-cases deserve the same honesty, because they're the strongest ones. The civil rights settlement of the 1960s was real — a dominant majority did extend the vote and pry the door open. It also took years of marching, people beaten bloody on bridges, and the Cold War embarrassment of preaching freedom abroad while denying it at home. New Zealand has built something like genuine power-sharing with the Māori — as repair for a treaty it had already broken, and it's contested and half-reversed even now.

Look at what all of them have in common. The sharing came only under duress. Revolt, war, shame, a broken promise finally called due.

So what are we actually asking of white America?

Let me be honest about it, because we don't say it plainly enough. We're asking a dominant group to voluntarily share power — and share thriving — with people it was taught to see as beneath it. No revolt forcing the issue. No war lost. No army at the gates. Just the choice, made freely.

That has almost no precedent. Not at this scale, not by anyone. What we are asking for is, in the most literal sense, unprecedented — a thing the human record does not contain.

This is the part worth sitting with, because the easy answer — they're just bad people — is both too flattering and too weak. Too flattering, because it lets the rest of us off the hook, as if we're a different species who'd have done better. Too weak, because it doesn't explain a pattern this old and this universal.

The harder answer is that this is how humans are. For all of recorded history, groups have hoarded advantage and built elaborate stories to justify it afterward. We are wired to sort the world into us and them, to feel the thriving of the out-group as a threat rather than a gain, even when the math says otherwise. The racism is, in a cold descriptive sense, understandable — not right, not defensible, but understandable as a thing our species reliably does. Every empire did it. Every majority did it. The impulse runs deeper than argument, which is why argument alone has never once been enough to dislodge it.

And here's the tension I won't pretend to resolve. Either the people on top genuinely cannot see the benefit — the hatred fogs the glass, and the obvious gain stays invisible to them — or they see it perfectly well and won't move anyway, because being superior is worth more to them than being better off. Call it a failure of vision or a failure of will. I don't know which it is, and it may be both — different people, different days. But here's what matters: it doesn't decide the outcome, because neither one has ever been beaten by a dominant majority acting on its own. That's the wall. That's why this is hard. Not because the case is weak — because the case was never what the decision turned on.

You can read me anywhere. There are louder takes. There are faster newsfeeds. There are bigger names. What you get here that you don’t get anywhere else is THE SPINE — a permanent argumentative scaffold you can stand on, walk along, share with the people you’re trying to convince, and keep coming back to over years.

The reason your premium went up $1,000. The reason your sister’s cancer trial got pulled. The reason Pap smears are disappearing from rural counties. THEY ARE THE SAME REASON. That’s the case we’re making, week after week, until the country can see it.

Thank you for being here. Forward this to one person who needs the spine.

— YC
Dr. Yamicia Connor, MD, PhD, MPH · Founder & CEO, Diosa Ara | Creator & Editor-in-Chief, The Labora Collective